Atlanta Duplicate Bridge Center    

6761 Peachtree Industrial Boulevard, Suite 200                   

Atlanta, Georgia 30360            (770) 248-0306

 

EVENT>Thursday Morning 299er   |SESSION>Thursday Morn|SECTION> C
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>December 22, 2011  |CLUB NO.>113712    | 12/22/2011 14:06
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> Alvin Daigle    |RATING>Club Championship (70%, 60%, 60% Open)|MOVEMENT>ONE WINNER
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   36.0 |TOP>   3 |MP LIMITS>200/100/50     |CLUB>Atlanta Duplicate Bridge
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=8/B=6/C=4                       ,---,-----------------,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |      Overall    |           Section       |      |Final    |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Jo Dunlop              Bobbye Hightower         C   .     .     .   |   .     .     .     32.50  45.14          
 2 Connie Melgaard        Chris DiMuzio            B   2     1     .   |   2     1     .     42.50  59.03  0.85(OB)
 3 Judi Carter            Linda Doherty            A   1     .     .   |   1     .     .     43.00  59.72  1.06(OA)
 4 Ann Benson             Laura Sibille            C   .     .     .   |   .     .     .     27.50  38.19          
 5 Crystal Schmindt       Tom Stuetzer             C   .     .     .   |   .     .    1/2    33.00  45.83  0.21(SC)
 6 Jenny Magid            Janet Brewer             C   .     .     .   |   .     .    1/2    33.00  45.83  0.21(SC)
 7 Alice Jamieson         Beverly Wilkinson        A   .     .     .   |   .     .     .     34.50  47.92          
 8 Rochelle Derman        Manfred Derman           B   3     2     .   |   3     2     .     42.00  58.33  0.64(OB)

                                          Totals                                            288.00       


                        **PAIRS**
BOARD     1     2     3     4     5     6     7     8
  /
   1>     1     3     0     0     2     3     1     2 
         -90*  120  -120* -150    50*  150*  -50    90 

   2>     0      -    2-     -    1     2-    2     3 
        -600* -100   100* -100  -140*  100*  140   600 

   3>      -     -    2-    2-    2-     -     -    2-
         110* -130   130* -110   130*  110* -130  -110 

   4>     3     1     2     3     1     0     2     0 
        -150*  170  -170*  660  -650* -660*  650   150 

   5>     2      -    2-     -    1     3     0     2-
        -620* -650*  650  -650*  620   100* -100   650 

   6>     2-    2-    2     1      -    0     3      -
         630*  630* -600   600* -630  -100*  100  -630 

   7>     1     3     3     0     2     2     1     0 
         690* 1440* -620   620* -690   720* -720 -1440 

   8>     2     2     3     0     1     2     1     1 
         450*  450* -100   100* -450   450* -450  -450 

   9>     2     3      -    2-     -    0     1     2-
         170*  660*  140* -140   140* -660  -170  -140 

  10>      -     -    3     1     2     2-    2-    0 
         130*  130*  600* -170   170* -130  -130  -600 

  11>     1-    1-    3     3     0     1-    1-    0 
         140*  140*  170*  100  -100* -140  -140  -170 

  12>     2     1     0     0     3     2     1     3 
        -100* -110* -130* -100   100*  110   100   130 

  13>     1     3     2     1     0     3     0     2 
        -130   140   130*  110* -150   150* -140* -110 

  14>     2-    0      -     -    1     2     3     2-
         150  -170  -150* -150*   50   -50*  170*  150 

  15>     0     2     3     0     1     2     1     3 
        -100   630   100* -790*  620  -620* -630*  790 

  16>     0     1-    3     1-    3     0     1-    1-
        -100   110   100* -110*  140  -140* -110*  110 

  17>      -    1     2-    2     3     2-     -    0 
        -460*  430   460  -430*  100*  460  -460* -100 

  18>     2-    3      -    0     1      -    2-    2 
         120*  200  -120  -200*  -50* -120   120*   50 

  19>     2     3     0     0     1     1     3     2 
          90*  500  -110  -500* -200*  -90   110*  200 

  20>     3     1     2     2     0     0     1     3 
         620* -500   100   500* -200* -620  -100*  200 

  21>     1     2     3     0     0     1     3     2 
        -420   420*   50  -450   -50*  140*  450* -140 

  22>     1     2     1     3     2     2     0     1 
        -650   650* -650   100   650*  650* -100* -650 

  23>     1     2     0     2     3     0     1     3 
         140  -140*  120   620  -120* -790* -620*  790 

  24>     0     3     1-    1-    1-    0     1-    3 
        -510   510* -420  -420   420*  190*  420* -190 






Thursday Morning 299er, Thursday Morn, December 22, 2011


Board 1
North Deals
None Vul
♠ K J 4 2
9
A 7 5 3
♣ K 6 3 2
♠ 10 9 8
K J 6 2
K Q 4
♣ 7 5 4
N
WE
S
♠ Q 5 3
10 5 3
J 10 8 2
♣ Q J 10
♠ A 7 6
A Q 8 7 4
9 6
♣ A 9 8

NS 3♠; NS 3; NS 2N; NS 3♣; NS 2

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1203.000.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 3-Carter-Doherty
902.001.008-Derman-Derman vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
501.002.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
1500.003.004-Benson-Sibille vs 6-Magid-Brewer

Board 2
East Deals
N-S Vul
♠ A K 9 3 2
A 10
Q 8 4
♣ K 10 7
♠ Q J 10 6
9 8 7 3
K 9 3
♣ Q J
N
WE
S
♠ 7
K J 5
10 6 5 2
♣ 8 6 5 3 2
♠ 8 5 4
Q 6 4 2
A J 7
♣ A 9 4

NS 4N; NS 4♠; NS 3; NS 3♣; NS 2

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
6003.000.008-Derman-Derman vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
1402.001.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
1000.502.502-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 3-Carter-Doherty
1000.502.504-Benson-Sibille vs 6-Magid-Brewer

Board 3
South Deals
E-W Vul
♠ K 9 7 3 2
Q 9 3
K 5 4
♣ Q 10
♠ 10 4
A 6
A Q J 7 3
♣ K J 9 3
N
WE
S
♠ A Q 8 6
10 7 4 2
9 8 6
♣ 7 2
♠ J 5
K J 8 5
10 2
♣ A 8 6 5 4

W 4; EW 2N; E 3; EW 1♠; NS 1; EW 1♣

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1102.500.504-Benson-Sibille vs 6-Magid-Brewer
1102.500.508-Derman-Derman vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
1300.502.502-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 3-Carter-Doherty
1300.502.507-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer

Board 4
West Deals
Both Vul
♠ A J 10 5
K 7
K 10 6 3
♣ 6 3 2
♠ 9 4
Q 10
A 9 7 4
♣ K 9 8 7 5
N
WE
S
♠ K 8 6 3 2
9 5 3
Q J 8
♣ J 4
♠ Q 7
A J 8 6 4 2
5 2
♣ A Q 10

S 5; NS 4N; N 4; NS 2♠; NS 2; NS 1♣

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
6603.000.004-Benson-Sibille vs 6-Magid-Brewer
6502.001.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
1701.002.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 3-Carter-Doherty
1500.003.008-Derman-Derman vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower

Board 5
North Deals
N-S Vul
♠ K Q 6 3 2
A K 9 8 6
A 3
♣ J
♠ 8 7 5
Q 7 2
6
♣ A 10 8 7 5 2
N
WE
S
♠ J
J 10 5 4 3
Q 4 2
♣ Q 6 4 3
♠ A 10 9 4

K J 10 9 8 7 5
♣ K 9

S 6N; NS 6♠; S 6; N 5; S 2; N 1N; EW 2♣; N 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
6502.500.503-Carter-Doherty vs 4-Benson-Sibille
6502.500.508-Derman-Derman vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio
6201.002.005-Schmindt-Stuetzer vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
1000.003.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 6-Magid-Brewer

Board 6
East Deals
E-W Vul
♠ Q 4
J 10 5
10 6 3 2
♣ K 9 6 4
♠ A J 10 9 3
A 2
9 8
♣ Q 10 8 2
N
WE
S
♠ 8 6
K 9 6 3
A K Q 7 5
♣ A 5
♠ K 7 5 2
Q 8 7 4
J 4
♣ J 7 3

EW 4N; EW 4♠; EW 5; EW 3; EW 3♣

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1003.000.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 6-Magid-Brewer
6002.001.003-Carter-Doherty vs 4-Benson-Sibille
6300.502.505-Schmindt-Stuetzer vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
6300.502.508-Derman-Derman vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio

Board 7
South Deals
Both Vul
♠ Q 9
6 5 4 2
A 10 9 8 5 3
♣ 9
♠ K J 2
A Q 8 3
K Q
♣ A K 8 7
N
WE
S
♠ A 7 6 3
K 9
4
♣ J 10 6 5 4 2
♠ 10 8 5 4
J 10 7
J 7 6 2
♣ Q 3

EW 6N; EW 6; EW 6♣; EW 5♠; EW 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
6203.000.003-Carter-Doherty vs 4-Benson-Sibille
6902.001.005-Schmindt-Stuetzer vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
7201.002.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 6-Magid-Brewer
14400.003.008-Derman-Derman vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio

Board 8
West Deals
None Vul
♠ 10 5
9 7 6
A 8 6 2
♣ Q 10 5 2
♠ Q J 4 2
K Q 3
9 5 3
♣ 9 7 3
N
WE
S
♠ A 7
A J 10 5 4 2
K Q J 10 7
♣ —
♠ K 9 8 6 3
8
4
♣ A K J 8 6 4

EW 4; NS 5♣; EW 4; N 2♠; S 1♠

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1003.000.003-Carter-Doherty vs 4-Benson-Sibille
4501.002.005-Schmindt-Stuetzer vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
4501.002.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 6-Magid-Brewer
4501.002.008-Derman-Derman vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio

Board 9
North Deals
E-W Vul
♠ Q 6
9 8 6 5
K J 7 5 3
♣ Q 4
♠ 10 9 8 7 3 2
10 2
10 9 6
♣ K 10
N
WE
S
♠ A 4
A K Q 3
A 2
♣ A 9 8 5 2
♠ K J 5
J 7 4
Q 8 4
♣ J 7 6 3

EW 4♠; E 4; W 3; EW 4♣; EW 2N; EW 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1402.500.504-Benson-Sibille vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
1402.500.508-Derman-Derman vs 3-Carter-Doherty
1701.002.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
6600.003.006-Magid-Brewer vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio

Board 10
East Deals
Both Vul
♠ A K J 10 5
Q 9 7
K 5 4
♣ 7 2
♠ Q 9 3
A K 3 2
A Q 7
♣ 10 5 3
N
WE
S
♠ 8 2
10 8 5
10 9 3
♣ A K Q J 8
♠ 7 6 4
J 6 4
J 8 6 2
♣ 9 6 4

W 4; W 3N; E 3; W 4♣; E 2N; E 3♣; W 2; W 1♠; E 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1302.500.506-Magid-Brewer vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio
1302.500.507-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
1701.002.004-Benson-Sibille vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
6000.003.008-Derman-Derman vs 3-Carter-Doherty

Board 11
South Deals
None Vul
♠ K 10 7 3
7 3
10 9 3
♣ A 10 5 4
♠ J 9 4
10 9 4 2
Q 5 2
♣ J 3 2
N
WE
S
♠ 6 5
A K Q J 5
A 7 6 4
♣ K Q
♠ A Q 8 2
8 6
K J 8
♣ 9 8 7 6

EW 3; EW 3; EW 1N; NS 1♠; NS 1♣

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1003.000.004-Benson-Sibille vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
1401.501.506-Magid-Brewer vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio
1401.501.507-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
1700.003.008-Derman-Derman vs 3-Carter-Doherty

Board 12
West Deals
N-S Vul
♠ A 10 6
Q 7 5 3 2
Q 9 3
♣ Q 2
♠ Q J 7 2
J 4
K 10
♣ K J 6 5 3
N
WE
S
♠ 9 4
K 10 9 8 6
8 7
♣ A 9 8 4
♠ K 8 5 3
A
A J 6 5 4 2
♣ 10 7

NS 3; EW 2♣; NS 1♠; EW 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1303.000.008-Derman-Derman vs 3-Carter-Doherty
1102.001.006-Magid-Brewer vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio
1001.002.007-Jamieson-Wilkinson vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
1000.003.004-Benson-Sibille vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer

Board 13
North Deals
Both Vul
♠ A 8
10 9 8 7 6 3
8 5
♣ J 6 2
♠ K 9 6
Q 2
Q 9 3 2
♣ K 9 8 5
N
WE
S
♠ 7 5
A K J 5 4
A K 10 7 4
♣ 3
♠ Q J 10 4 3 2

J 6
♣ A Q 10 7 4

EW 4N; NS 3♠; EW 2; E 3; W 2; NS 2♣

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1403.000.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
1102.001.008-Derman-Derman vs 4-Benson-Sibille
1301.002.001-Dunlop-Hightower vs 3-Carter-Doherty
1500.003.005-Schmindt-Stuetzer vs 6-Magid-Brewer

Board 14
East Deals
None Vul
♠ 8 2
J 5
Q 8 5 4
♣ A J 10 9 2
♠ A J
8 7
A K 10 6 2
♣ K 8 6 4
N
WE
S
♠ K Q 9 6 3
Q 10 9 6 4
7 3
♣ 7
♠ 10 7 5 4
A K 3 2
J 9
♣ Q 5 3

EW 3♠; W 3; E 2; NS 1N; NS 2♣; W 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1502.500.501-Dunlop-Hightower vs 3-Carter-Doherty
1502.500.508-Derman-Derman vs 4-Benson-Sibille
501.002.005-Schmindt-Stuetzer vs 6-Magid-Brewer
1700.003.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson

Board 15
South Deals
N-S Vul
♠ A K Q 6
Q J 4
8 4
♣ K Q J 2
♠ J 10 8 3
10 9 6
K J 10 7
♣ 9 8
N
WE
S
♠ 5
K 8 3 2
A 6 2
♣ 10 7 6 5 4
♠ 9 7 4 2
A 7 5
Q 9 5 3
♣ A 3

NS 4♠; NS 3N; NS 2; NS 2♣; NS 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
7903.000.008-Derman-Derman vs 4-Benson-Sibille
6302.001.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
6201.002.005-Schmindt-Stuetzer vs 6-Magid-Brewer
1000.003.001-Dunlop-Hightower vs 3-Carter-Doherty

Board 16
West Deals
E-W Vul
♠ K J 8
A Q J 10 7
A J
♣ J 9 7
♠ A 7
K 6
8 7 5 4
♣ A K 8 4 2
N
WE
S
♠ Q 4 3
9 8 5 3
Q 10 3 2
♣ 10 3
♠ 10 9 6 5 2
4 2
K 9 6
♣ Q 6 5

NS 2N; NS 2♠; NS 2; W 2; E 1; W 1♣

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1403.000.005-Schmindt-Stuetzer vs 6-Magid-Brewer
1101.501.502-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
1101.501.508-Derman-Derman vs 4-Benson-Sibille
1000.003.001-Dunlop-Hightower vs 3-Carter-Doherty

Board 17
North Deals
None Vul
♠ A J 9 3
A J 7 4 2
7 6
♣ J 10
♠ 7 6 2
Q 6
Q 10 5 4 3
♣ A 9 5
N
WE
S
♠ K Q 8
10 9 8 5
9 2
♣ 8 7 4 2
♠ 10 5 4
K 3
A K J 8
♣ K Q 6 3

NS 4N; NS 4♠; NS 4; NS 4♣; S 3; N 2

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
4602.500.503-Carter-Doherty vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
4602.500.506-Magid-Brewer vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
4301.002.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 4-Benson-Sibille
1000.003.008-Derman-Derman vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer

Board 18
East Deals
N-S Vul
♠ K 7
K 8 5 4 2
Q 10 7
♣ A 9 2
♠ A 4
6 3
A J 8 4 2
♣ J 10 7 3
N
WE
S
♠ Q 10 9
A J 10 7
9 3
♣ K Q 8 4
♠ J 8 6 5 3 2
Q 9
K 6 5
♣ 6 5

EW 2N; S 2♠; EW 3♣; EW 2; N 1♠; EW 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
2003.000.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 4-Benson-Sibille
502.001.008-Derman-Derman vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
1200.502.503-Carter-Doherty vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
1200.502.506-Magid-Brewer vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower

Board 19
South Deals
E-W Vul
♠ J 7 6
K J 5
7 6 4
♣ Q 9 6 3
♠ 9 5 4 3 2
9 6

♣ A J 10 8 5 2
N
WE
S
♠ Q
A 8 7 3
A J 10 9 8 5 2
♣ 7
♠ A K 10 8
Q 10 4 2
K Q 3
♣ K 4

NS 4N; S 1♠; NS 1; EW 1; S 1♣

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
5003.000.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 4-Benson-Sibille
2002.001.008-Derman-Derman vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
901.002.006-Magid-Brewer vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower
1100.003.003-Carter-Doherty vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson

Board 20
West Deals
Both Vul
♠ A J 10 9 8 3 2
10 9
4
♣ A 5 3
♠ 4
J 7 6 5 3
K 10 5 3
♣ 10 9 8
N
WE
S
♠ K Q
A K Q 8 4
Q 6 2
♣ K Q 2
♠ 7 6 5
2
A J 9 8 7
♣ J 7 6 4

NS 3♠; EW 3; EW 2

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
2003.000.008-Derman-Derman vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
1002.001.003-Carter-Doherty vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
5001.002.002-Melgaard-DiMuzio vs 4-Benson-Sibille
6200.003.006-Magid-Brewer vs 1-Dunlop-Hightower

Board 21
North Deals
N-S Vul
♠ 8 6
Q J 10 5 3
K Q J 8 5
♣ 5
♠ A 7 3 2
8 2
A 10 7 4
♣ 8 3 2
N
WE
S
♠ Q J 10 5
A K 7
6 2
♣ K Q J 9
♠ K 9 4
9 6 4
9 3
♣ A 10 7 6 4

EW 4♠; EW 3N; EW 4♣; NS 2; EW 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
503.000.003-Carter-Doherty vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
1402.001.008-Derman-Derman vs 6-Magid-Brewer
4201.002.001-Dunlop-Hightower vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio
4500.003.004-Benson-Sibille vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson

Board 22
East Deals
E-W Vul
♠ 9 5
Q J 2
A 8 7 5
♣ Q 10 8 5
♠ A J 10 8 6
A 8 6 5
6 4
♣ A 3
N
WE
S
♠ K Q 2
K 10 9 7 3
K
♣ K J 6 4
♠ 7 4 3
4
Q J 10 9 3 2
♣ 9 7 2

W 6♠; E 5♠; EW 5; EW 3♣; EW 1N; NS 1

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1003.000.004-Benson-Sibille vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
6501.002.001-Dunlop-Hightower vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio
6501.002.003-Carter-Doherty vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
6501.002.008-Derman-Derman vs 6-Magid-Brewer

Board 23
South Deals
Both Vul
♠ A K 8 5
A Q 10
Q 9
♣ K Q 9 2
♠ Q 10 7 6 4 3
K 9
7 5
♣ J 8 4
N
WE
S
♠ —
4 3 2
A K 10 8 4
♣ A 7 6 5 3
♠ J 9 2
J 8 7 6 5
J 6 3 2
♣ 10

N 4; S 3; NS 2N; NS 1♠; NS 1; EW 1♣

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
7903.000.008-Derman-Derman vs 6-Magid-Brewer
6202.001.004-Benson-Sibille vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
1401.002.001-Dunlop-Hightower vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio
1200.003.003-Carter-Doherty vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer

Board 24
West Deals
None Vul
♠ A K 10 9 4
5 2
J 8 5
♣ 9 8 3
♠ Q 8
A Q 8
K 6
♣ K Q 7 5 4 2
N
WE
S
♠ —
K 9 7 6 3
A Q 9 7 4 2
♣ A 10
♠ J 7 6 5 3 2
J 10 4
10 3
♣ J 6

EW 7; EW 7; EW 7♣; EW 1N

ScoresMatchpointsPairs
N-SE-WN-SE-W
1903.000.008-Derman-Derman vs 6-Magid-Brewer
4201.501.503-Carter-Doherty vs 5-Schmindt-Stuetzer
4201.501.504-Benson-Sibille vs 7-Jamieson-Wilkinson
5100.003.001-Dunlop-Hightower vs 2-Melgaard-DiMuzio